|
Forwarded this? Subscribe here and get it every Tuesday.
|
The Brave New Business Journal
Issue 23 · Tuesday 6 October 2026 · from Anne Becheru
Five questions before you hire a marketing agency
|
|
Tuesday mornings. One idea, one question, one thing to try.
|
|
From Anne
Early in my career, a man at a dinner asked what I did. I said marketing.
“Oh. But you seem clever.”
He meant it kindly. That was the worst part.
And the reputation was not unfair. Mark Ritson tested marketers on their own fundamentals this year with Ipsos. Two-thirds of UK marketers failed. Only about a third have any formal training. Eighty-four per cent rated themselves above average.
Some of those people are pitching you this quarter.
So here are the five questions I would ask before signing with any marketing supplier. Including mine.
|
|
Five questions before you hire an agency
|
|
Judge an agency by its questions, not its answers.
The weak ones ask about your target audience, your tone of voice, which competitors you admire, and what you want the campaign to achieve.
The ones worth hiring ask where the money actually comes from. Which lines carry the margin and which only carry volume. How long the sales cycle really is and where deals die. Who signs, and who can quietly block it. What a customer is worth over three years. Which SKU you would kill if nobody was watching.
If nobody in that room asks a question that makes you slightly uncomfortable about your own numbers, they are planning to decorate.
|
| 2 |
What happened to the last company like mine that hired them? |
Not the logo wall. What happened, and to whom.
Agencies show consumer brands to industrial clients and hope the glamour transfers. Ask for one client in your category, at your scale, and ask what changed. If the answer is awards and impressions, they measured activity.
|
| 3 |
Who will actually do the work? |
You are meeting the senior people because this is a pitch. Ask who is on the account in month four, how many other clients that person carries, and what happens when they leave.
The most common failure in agency relationships, and almost nobody asks it before signing.
|
| 4 |
Can they market themselves? |
The one that tells you most and nobody checks.
Did you think of them, or did they appear in your inbox? Are they known in your sector, cited by anyone, findable when you search the problem rather than their name?
An agency's own marketing is its proof of concept. If they cannot make themselves known in a category they claim to understand, you are buying a theory.
|
| 5 |
What can they say that the other two cannot? |
Put the three proposals side by side and strike out every claim all three make. Strategic. Data-driven. Senior attention. True partnership.
What survives is your decision. Sometimes nothing survives, which also tells you something.
|
|
Now the uncomfortable part
Four of those five are the principles of marketing. Social proof, recommendation, availability, value.
The first one is different. Business acumen is the test of whether they can apply any of the other four to a business rather than to a brand guideline. It is why it goes first, and it is the one most agencies fail quietly, because nobody grades a pitch on the questions asked in it.
And your own buyers are running the same five on you.
Most companies score worst on the fourth. If you are not there when a shortlist gets written from memory, nothing else about you gets assessed.
|
|
Two things worth knowing
Availability beats everything, and you already run half of it. Physical availability is distribution, fill rate, OTIF. You measure it weekly. Mental availability is the same thing in a buyer's head, and almost nobody measures it.
Scarcity and availability are opposites. One says be harder to get, the other says be easier to buy. You know which wins, because when a line goes out of stock nobody in your business calls it a scarcity benefit. You call it lost sales.
Sources: Ritson and Ipsos, 2026. Sharp, How Brands Grow.
|
But what about the quiet ones?
You are thinking of a specific supplier. No marketing, very good business.
If forty buyers exist and all forty know the name, that is not low availability. That is total availability, in a market of forty.
The test: could they become well known if they decided to? If not, that is not mystery. That is obscurity, and someone has started calling it discretion.
|
|
One thing to do this week
Run the five on your current agency. Start with the first one, and be honest about what they asked you before they pitched.
Then run them on us.
I would rather be measured properly than chosen by accident, and if we fail one of the five I would like to know which.
|
|
Before you go
Write back and tell me which question you would add. The disagreements are more useful than the agreements.
And if anyone says you seem too clever for marketing, send them the Ritson numbers.
|
Anne
The Brave New Business Journal · Issue 23
|
|
|
About Brave New
B2B communications and marketing for capital, industry and healthcare. We work with companies that are excellent at the hard thing and under-told about it.
Every engagement starts with the Audit. Send your numbers, and three days later you get one page: where you stand, what it costs, what we would fix first. Yours to keep, either way.
brave-new.com
|
Visit brave-new.com to see who we are, how we work, and what we refuse to do.
You are receiving this because you subscribed to The Brave New Business Journal.
Unsubscribe
|